『When the Promises of the Past Collide with Love in the Present: The Temperature of Friendship Revealed Over One Weekend』
🎥 Film Overview
🎬 Title: Everything Relative (1996)
🌍 Country: 🇺🇸 United States
🎞️ Genre: Drama / Comedy / LGBT
⏳ Runtime: 110 minutes (approximately 1 hour 50 minutes)
📢 Director: Sharon Pollack
🖋️ Screenplay: Sharon Pollack
📺 Distribution/Screenings: Tara Releasing / Screened at Sundance Film Festival, etc.
👩💼 Cast: Ellen McLaughlin – Josie, Stacey Nelkin – Katie Kessler
Monica Bell – Victoria, Olivia Negrón – Maria
Dreya Weber – Luce, Gabriella Messina – Gina
Carol Schneider – Sarah
🧩 Deep Story Exploration (Spoilers)
🎈 The ‘Big Chill’ Structure and the Collision of Queer Identity
《Everything Relative》is a weekend comedy-drama about seven women who were once college friends and political activists, reuniting after many years. The film candidly portrays the gap between ideology and reality, and the complexity of relationships that these second-wave feminists and lesbians experience as time passes.
🔄 The Structural Device of Reunion
The film begins when the two lesbian partners Katie and Victoria have a son and host a Bris (a Jewish circumcision and naming ceremony), prompting their friends to gather at a rural house near Northampton, Massachusetts.
This kind of “class reunion/gathering” structure effectively contrasts the idealized past with the messy realities of the present. Once radical student activists in the 1970s, the women are now integrated into society as a lawyer, a therapist, a writer, a stuntwoman, and more. Their relationships and political convictions are put to the test within the life of middle age.
🧭 The Compromise Between Ideology and Reality
The film directly applies the second-wave feminist slogan, “the personal is political,” to the characters’ everyday lives.
- Victoria and Katie: As a lesbian couple and new parents, they find joy in the birth of their child. However, Victoria, a high-ranking attorney, hesitates to come out because of her career, causing conflict with her live-in partner Katie. This portrays the joy of family-making and the pressure of social concealment that many LGBTQ+ couples faced in the 1990s.
- Maria and Josie: The most intense conflict erupts between Maria and her former lover Josie. Maria left Josie in the past to pursue a “normal life,” marrying a man and having children—yet later came out as a lesbian and lost custody, now fighting a difficult legal battle. Josie, a recovering alcoholic unable to heal from the pain, cannot forgive Maria. Their reunion forces them to confront past betrayal and identity turmoil.
👩❤️💋👩 Harmony Within the Ensemble Cast
One of the film’s strongest elements is its ensemble cast. Director Pollack gives all seven characters ample narrative weight and individuality, allowing the audience to empathize with their lives and conflicts. In particular, the complex and emotional portrayal of Maria and Josie’s relationship received praise from critics.
🧊 The “Token Heterosexual” and the White-Centered Narrative
- Sarah, the group’s only heterosexual friend, struggles with infertility and deeply longs for a child. She serves as both an outsider observing the world of her lesbian friends and a symbol of the universal concern of motherhood experienced by many women.
However, some critics pointed out that the film focuses primarily on white middle-class women, lacking the lens of intersectionality emphasized by third-wave feminism emerging at the time. This can be seen as a historical limitation reflecting the perspective and community of the period in which the film was created.
💡 The Aesthetic and Atmosphere of Independent Cinema
《Everything Relative》has the roughness and sincerity typical of low-budget independent films. Rather than focusing on polished direction, the film emphasizes the density of dialogue and relationships among the characters. Some critics found the dialogue occasionally “preachy” or somewhat cliché, but this honesty instead gives the film the power to convey a story from within the community with vivid authenticity.
👍 A Classic of 1990s Lesbian Cinema
The 1990s were a period of revival for a new wave of lesbian cinema, and this film occupies an important place within that movement. Its blend of lesbian everyday life, relationships, and political convictions—told through humor and drama—helped establish it as a must-watch in queer cinema. Elements like the montage set to Ani DiFranco’s music capture the specific cultural sensibility of the era.
📜 Reflections of 1970s Feminists in the 1990s
《Everything Relative》may not be a perfect film, but it remains a valuable archive capturing the lives of the 1990s lesbian community and the generational and personal conflicts they experienced. True to its title “Everything Relative,” the film shows how life, love, and politics continually shift and compromise over time. Through the reunion of old friends, the film offers a message of healing past wounds and affirming life in the present—a message that resonates beyond its era.
🎯 Personal (Taste-Based) Rating
💕 Love Scene Intensity: ♥♥♥
⭐ Rating: ★★★
Comments
Post a Comment