Josie and Finch: A Couple's Story from Legacies

🌙 『Legacies』 – Blossoming Love Within a Supernatural Coming-of-Age Tale

🎥 Series Overview

🎬 Title: Legacies (2018–2022)
🌍 Country: 🇺🇸 United States
📺 Network: The CW
🌍 Universe: Sequel to 『The Vampire Diaries』 and 『The Originals』
🎞️ Genre: Fantasy / Teen Drama / Supernatural
🗓️ Seasons: 4 seasons, 68 episodes total
🏢 Creator: Julie Plec

👩‍💼 Cast: Kaylee Bryant (also credited as Kaylee Kaneshiro) – Josie Saltzman
Courtney Bandeko – Finch Tarrayo

🧩 Deep Story Exploration (Spoilers)

🧙‍♀️ A ‘Healthy’ Connection with the Outside World

Finch makes her first appearance in Season 3, when Josie briefly transfers to Mystic Falls High School. Their relationship begins with a very different dynamic compared to Josie’s previous, darker or more emotionally dependent connections.

• Josie’s Transformation: Finch appears at a moment when Josie is attempting to move away from her long-standing dependence on Lizzie and the dangerous “Dark Josie” magic. Finch encourages her to stop her pattern of people-pleasing and instead focus on her own needs and desires.
• Rapid Progression and Criticism: Their romance progresses quite rapidly. Some viewers criticized the pacing, arguing that their relationship felt rushed and lacking emotional foundation. Additionally, the fact that Finch became deeply involved with Josie before fully learning about her supernatural background — being a witch, twin, and potential Merge participant — was seen as a narrative flaw.

🐺 Honesty and Conflict

When it’s revealed that Finch is not a simple human but a werewolf, and she later joins the Salvatore School, their relationship becomes more complex and emotionally charged.

• Pursuit of Honesty: Finch directly challenges Josie to choose between having a “fun, easy, and stable relationship” or a “honest, difficult, but growth-oriented one.” This confrontation pushes Josie to face her long-suppressed insecurities and emotional avoidance.
• Werewolf Anxiety: After learning about Josie’s looming Merge destiny, Finch begins to fear that the event will destroy their relationship. Josie, however, confides that she needs someone who will love and stand by her regardless of the outcome. Finch accepts Josie’s truth and remains a devoted partner despite the uncertainty.
• Healthy Communication: Unlike many of Josie’s past entanglements, their relationship focuses on communication rather than control or rescue, marking one of the few emotionally balanced romances in the show’s universe.

✍️ The Narrative Flop

When Josie exits the series in Season 4, her relationship with Finch abruptly ends — a conclusion that sparked considerable criticism.

• Sudden Breakup: Josie decides to leave town with Finch to escape the chaos between Lizzie and Hope. However, Finch soon realizes that she has become the new Alpha of the wolf pack and chooses to stay behind to lead them. This decision leaves Josie alone once again.
• Lack of Conviction: The scene attempts to portray a fated, bittersweet separation, yet many viewers found Josie’s decision inconsistent. After giving up everything to leave with Finch, Josie suddenly departs without her when Finch can’t come along — making it appear as though Josie used the relationship as a means of escape. This undermines the emotional growth and self-realization Josie had achieved through their relationship.

👩‍❤️‍👩 “Finsie”

Josie and Finch’s relationship marks a pivotal chapter in Josie’s character arc. Finch serves as a catalyst for Josie to discover what she truly wants beyond the influence of others. As a queer romance, their dynamic received positive recognition for its authenticity. However, due to Kaylee Bryant’s departure from the show, the series ended their storyline prematurely — leaving Finch’s potential and the theme of “a healthy relationship” underdeveloped and bittersweet.

🎯 Personal Rating

💕 Love Scene Intensity: ♥♥
⭐ Rating: ★★★