『A Steadfast Love and Survival Between Two Women Amid Family Prejudice and Social Pressure』
🎥 Movie Overview
🎬 Title: Treading Water (2001)
🌍 Country: 🇺🇸 United States
🎞️ Genre: Drama / Romance / Social Conflict
📢 Director/Screenwriters: Lauren Himmel & Julia Hollinger
👩💼 Cast: Angela Redman – Casey Olsen
Nina Landey – Alex Barrett-Rosenberg
🧩 Deep Story Exploration (Spoilers)
🌊 Hidden ‘Normalcy’ and Their Safe Haven
Casey and Alex’s love feels “normal” and peaceful only when they are together. However, that peace is always fragile—constantly under threat from the outside world, making it something they can never fully enjoy.
- Background: Casey is the daughter of a devout Catholic family that completely denies her homosexuality. Alex, meanwhile, is not only Casey’s lover but also—ironically—her drug-addicted brother Andrew’s therapist.
- Role Division and Safe Haven: For Casey, Alex represents a space of emotional safety. Under the heavy weight of familial pressure and confusion about her identity, her relationship with Alex becomes the only place where she can rest as her true self. In their private space, they share love and trust just like any other heterosexual couple.
- Disguise in the Outside World: The fact that Alex is accepted by Casey’s family under the false pretense of being “Andrew’s therapist” highlights the tragic core of their situation. The family welcomes Alex warmly—but that hospitality would vanish instantly if they learned the truth. Casey constantly faces a painful dilemma: must she choose between her family’s approval and her love for Alex?
🔐 Boundaries and Pressure
The main conflict in Casey and Alex’s relationship doesn’t arise from within—it’s the external pressure forcing Casey to choose between her family’s acceptance and Alex’s love.
- Family vs. Lover: During major family events like Christmas, Casey is constantly told to come “without Alex.” The unspoken message is clear: “If you abandon your love, we will accept you.”
- Instability of the Relationship (Treading Water): Alex suffers from frustration and pain as she watches Casey hide their relationship to maintain family ties. To Alex, Casey always seems to be “treading water,” barely staying afloat—haunted by the fear that she might one day let go and return to her family. The stability of their love depends entirely on Casey’s resolve to protect her identity and her love.
- The Barrier Named Andrew: Alex’s dual role as Andrew’s therapist intensifies the tension. Andrew develops feelings for Alex, which fuels Casey’s jealousy and discomfort. Because Alex must uphold professional ethics, she is forced to keep her relationship with Casey even more secret—adding yet another social restraint to their love.
⛵️ The Metaphor of “Treading Water” and an Unstable Life
The title Treading Water serves as a powerful metaphor for Casey’s emotional and relational struggles—her constant effort to stay afloat in a hostile environment.
- Emotional Exhaustion: Casey is torn between gaining her family’s approval and refusing to abandon her partner. Her life is a continuous balancing act, filled with anxiety and emotional fatigue, like someone desperately kicking to stay above water.
- Lack of a Safe Zone: Casey’s home is unsafe because her love isn’t accepted, yet her relationship with Alex must remain hidden from that same family. She exists as a “refugee between two worlds”—unable to find comfort or belonging in either.
Casey and Alex’s relationship stands at the crossroads of love, sacrifice, and identity politics. Their affection is genuine yet fragile, constantly shadowed by family hostility. Only Casey’s determination can keep their love alive.
🏳️🌈 A Snapshot of Early Queer Cinema
Treading Water (2001) emerged from the early 2000s American indie scene as one of the few films to tackle LGBTQ+ themes head-on, centering on the universal yet painful struggle for family acceptance. Although it received mixed reviews for its production quality, Casey’s inner turmoil resonates deeply with anyone who has faced rejection for their sexual orientation. The film captures a crucial chapter of early queer cinema—when lesbian couples had to fight just to be seen as “normal.”
🎯 Personal Rating (Based on Taste)
💕 Love Scene Intensity: ♥♥♥
⭐ Overall Rating: ★★★☆
Comments
Post a Comment